Sunday January 3, 2016

Saala Khadoos (Music review), Hindi – Santhosh Narayanan

Posted by Karthik

The instantly sing-along’ish title song comes alive in Vishal Dadlani’s angst’y vocals. In Jhalli pataka, Santhosh craftily mixes foot-tapping kuthu rhythms with a very blues’y tune and Sunidhi makes the odd combo work beautifully! Dil ye ladaku is Santhosh’s trademark sound, with a brilliant profusion of violins to help Monali’s tantalizing vocals. Jagaa khunnas is pulsating, rousing rock featuring Vishal Dadlani and Vijay Narayan, with nifty, catchy vocalization. Kalyani Nair’s Hindi has a freshly-learnt quality in Dhuaan, but Santhosh’s sweeping, poignant tune makes it easily work. Santhosh’s Hindi debut doesn’t break new ground like in Tamil, but it’s immensely listenable.

Note: The Tamil version of this soundtrack, for the film titled Irudhi Sutru, is identical to the Hindi soundtrack. But the level of detailing in differentiating this one from the Tamil version is pretty amazing. A separate review doesn’t make sense, but I do have some points to add with regard to Irudhi Sutru.

Saala khadoos and Poda poda: The Ooo chorus starts off even before Vishal starts singing, unlike in Tamil where it appears for the first time only when the first Poda poda is uttered by Pradeep. The Hindi version, also the title song, unlike the Tamil equivalent, is also decidedly more angsty in Vishal’s vocals than Pradeep’s I-am-free tone. Also missing in Hindi is the kind of pumped up sound that backs the first Saala khadoos uttering, and this is something that lifts the Tamil Poda poda beautifully.

Dhuaan hai and Usuru narambula nee: In Dhuaan hai, Kalyani Nair seems a bit handicapped by her freshly learnt quality of Hindi, but Dhee Venka is in stupendous form in the Tamil version of the highly engaging and pensive melody.

Jhalli pataka and Vaa machaney: The most dramatic difference is in Vaa machaney, what was a song from the girl’s point of view, singing about herself in Hindi, sung by Sunidhi Chauhan. In Tamil, the lyrics portray the female point of view too (Vaa machaney!), but is sung by Sean Roldan, who does a splendid job, as always.

Jagaa khunnas and Maya visai: Maya visai matches perfectly with its Hindi counterpart, Jagaa khunnas and the only interesting observation is the word ‘khunnas’ that seems more impactful compared to ‘maaya visai’ (invisible lever/switch)!

Dil ye ladaku and Ei sandakkaaraa: Ditto with Ei sandakkara, where the choice of singer makes perfect sense and big difference between this and the Hindi version, Dil ye ladaku. Monali Thakur’s version, lyrically, teases and tantalizes, articulating the girl’s perspective, while Dhee’s Tamil version seems more assertive where she calls the shots!

PS: This may be the oddest 200 on Milliblog yet. Yes, bumping it to a 200 as a combined, 2-language, 10-song compilation. As a combo, it flows so smootly and is darn good!

Keywords: Saala Khadoos, Santhosh Narayanan, Irudhi Sutru, 200, #200

Listen to the songs from Saala Khadoos on Gaana.
Listen to the songs from Irudhi Sutru on Saavn.

Comments

comments

  • Sathyajit Krishnan

    Scintillating from Santhosh. But I still have a feeling the songs are going to sound much better in Tamil.

  • hikicha

    Sir , this is called A/B testing in music :)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

    -MumbaiRamki

    • milliblog

      Hahaha… good one ๐Ÿ™‚

    • kadalamittai

      ๐Ÿ™‚ nice

  • Vijaynarain Rangarajan

    The opening para of Poda Poda is completely different, tune wise from its Hindi counterpart, if you noticed ๐Ÿ™‚ Also, Sandakkara and its Hindi version are in different pitches as well.

    • milliblog

      Indeed. I assumed it was to manage the different lyrical flow (hoping the lyrics were written first and the tune composed later). Great job on Jagaa khunnas/Maya visai btw ๐Ÿ™‚

      • Vijaynarain Rangarajan

        Yes, that’s kind of what happened. The tune was changed a bit to accommodate the Hindi lyrics. Thank you ๐Ÿ™‚

  • HKHR

    Is Ei sandakaara’s Dhee Venkateswaran Santhosh Narayanan’s daughter? She’s the one who sang Disco Woman from Pizza 2 – Villa. Man, she has a powerful voice.

    • Sai Prasanth

      No. Because Santhosh Narayanan is 32 years old & Dhee is 17. So not possible. ๐Ÿ˜„

      • Yegnaraman Venkat

        But she is the daughter of his wife Meenakshi Iyer.. If you browse through Meenakshi Iyer’s facebook profile.. you can come to know!! Also listen to Siddharth’s speech at Irudhi Suttru audio launch!!

        • Sai Prasanth

          Yes. Thanks for the info.

  • Nachi

    Maya Visai might be an Ode/ Tamil tribute to Eric Clapton’s Cocaine – Rock on Santosh Narayanan

  • jarinnickson

    Amidst all the faux sentimentality, we still get a protagonist that we canโ€™t help rooting for. That is the filmโ€™s real success. By far this movie is his careerโ€™s finest performance.
    Jogimara(dot)com/WebMusic

Sponsored links

January 2016
M T W T F S S
« Dec   Feb »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Like Milliblog? Help spread the word!

Get reviews by email